See Site links and related links

Formant Analysis of Certain "u" Vowels

I've made some formant computations in an effort to understand the differences between certain "u" vowels in words spoken by Larry Phillips. The segments I've analyzed are from the statement "too few avenues of communication".  The segments are the word "too", the word "few", the "ues" in" "avenues", and the "uni" in "communication".  The formants of Larry's vowels are shown in Figure 1.

To supply related information to help in understanding the formants of Larry's vowels, I've made and analyzed some recordings of certain of my pronunciations.  The analyses of these recordings are shown in the following figures:
2. My "he, who, hue" pronounced as I normally pronounce them, and
    My "he, who, hue" pronounced with an effort to move my tongue farther forward.
3. My "ee, oo, yoo, too" pronounced as I normally pronounce them
4. My pronunciations of "oo" preceded by various other consonants

In each of the formant plots, the bottom trace is "formant one", and the formants are in ascending order from bottom to top.  By convention, a vowel is more "forward" as the distance between formants one and two increases.  A vowel is "higher" as the frequency of formant one is lowered.

Figure 1:

Sorry.

Some significant features of figure 1 are

Figure 2 (left, normal pronunciation; right, tongue further forward):
Sorry.

In looking at figure 2, it's important to understand that an "h" preceding a vowel has little effect on the vowel.  Ladefoged, in his A Course in Phonetics, explains that an "h" doesn't have a position on the vowel chart of its own, but has formants that are about the same as the vowel that is to follow.  This makes "h-" words convenient to use in demonstrating vowel pronunciations: the vowel qualities are about the same as they would be without the "h".

Note that my diphthong in "hue" is similar to Larry's in "few", and the formants of my "who" are close to those at the ending of "hue".  The righthand part of figure 2 shows what happens when I make an effort to pronounce the "oo" sounds with my tongue farther forward than normal.  Note that in the case of "who" I didn't succeed in moving my tongue farther forward until the vowel had started, so there's a sharp raise in the frequency of the second formant at the beginning of "who".

Figure 3:
Sorry.

This figure shows the actual position of my "ee" sound.  It also shows that my "too" has a similar glide to Larry's, but it's not as great.  I find it interesting that in the case of these pronunciations of "you" and "too" the glide doesn't reach as far back as it does in my "hue" in figure 2.  If I were to make the same recording again, I wouldn't be surprised to find that those vowels did slide farther back.  Vowel qualities can change significantly from one utterance to another of the same speaker.

Figure 4:
Sorry.

I think the glides shown in this figure can be understood in each case by considering the position of the tongue when pronouncing the consonant preceding the vowel.  Note the difference in the sizes of the glides in "doo" and "too".  I do indeed find that when I pronounce "doo" my tongue is a little farther forward on the alveolar ridge than when I pronounce "too".

  by Bob Cunningham
See Site links and related links

This file was last modified 2003 May 27 (fixed broken links to sitelinks.html)